Canadian disease is the economic trouble that can be caused by canadas extraordinarily heavy reliance on the united. Harper government funded study arguing canada suffers from. Oct 02, 20 socalled dutch disease is only part of the issue. Dutch and canadian diseases serge coulombe department of economics, university of ottawa summary with the spectacular rise of the dollar, along with rising naturalresource prices during the first decade of the 21st century, canadians heard a great deal about dutch disease. Vu university amsterdam, the netherlands and serge coulombe. In economics, the dutch disease is the apparent causal relationship between the increase in the economic development of a specific sector for example natural resources and a decline in other sectors like the manufacturing sector or agriculture. Dutch disease arguments focus on the permanent loss of scale or spillovers in manufacturing industries on growth and wellbeing. Of far greater importance, says economics professor serge coulombe, is what he calls canadian disease. The canadian dollar and the dutch and canadian diseases by serge coulombe. Charna voki and dolado 2014 for an application to canada. The supreme court of canadas federalism as expressed in the securities reference pdf 601kb 2012. Pdf economists have long discussed the negative effect of dutch disease episodes on the nonresource tradable sector as a whole, but little. Ottawas focus on alberta oilsands is killing manufacturing.
Although believed to be originally native to asia, the disease was accidentally introduced into america and europe, where it has devastated native populations of elms that did not have resistance to the disease. Termsoftrade changes, the dutch disease, and canadian provincial disparity serge coulombe department of economics university of ottawa in this paper, i first show that canadian provincial disparities in 2012 have been essentially shaped by the relative evolution of regional terms of trade during the resource boom of 2002 to 2008. Harper govt funded study arguing canada suffers from. Challenges for policy makers, thinking outside the. Nov 15, 20 the dutch disease concept is very simpleoil and gas discoveries or, for that matter, rapid growth in any industry can cause resources to shift from other sectors, can increase net inflows of. Analysts claim canadian dollar overvalued by over 10%. Its a disease, the studies agree winnipeg free press. How to give meaning to canadian citizenship pdf 144kb 2008. Furthermore, beine, coulombe, and vermeulen 2014 show that the inflows of tfws contrary to those of permanent migrants could alleviate the potential dutch disease at the regional level that is associated with the big resource boom between 2001 and 2008. Using data for canadian provinces, we find evidence that aggregate immigration. Canadian policy prescriptions for dutch disease, by robin boadway, serge coulombe and jeanfrancois tremblay, can be downloaded from the institutes web site. The negative effects of a regional resource boom on the local manufacturing sector a phenomenon that economists call dutch disease can be partly mitigated by the arrival of temporary foreign workers and migrant labour from elsewhere in the country. Serge coulombe university of ottawa universite dottawa. Jan 18, 2017 for the disease affecting elm trees, see dutch elm disease.
Pdf trends in canadas merchandise trade semantic scholar. Coulombe, does the canadian economy suffer from dutch disease. Oct 10, 20 canadian policy prescriptions for dutch disease, by robin boadway, serge coulombe and jeanfrancois tremblay, can be downloaded from the institutes web site. Allcott, hunt and daniel keniston, dutch disease or agglomeration. In economics, the dutch disease is the apparent causal relationship between the increase in. As phrased by krugman 1987, the interesting question is why this phenomenon should be regarded as a disease. Mar 22, 2012 clean energy clean energy manufacturers spared from rising petrodollar job losses canadas clean economy has so far been spared the damaging effects of dutch disease caused by oil sands exports. Harper government funded study on dutch disease cbc news. This article evaluates whether immigration can mitigate the dutch disease effects associated with booms. We derive predicted changes in the size of the non. Canada has become more integrated with the world economy, and this openness is evident from its greater export orientation, its heavier reliance on imported inputs, and more exposure to foreign competition in its domestic markets. Receipt of fluoroquinolones was the predominant risk factor for clostridium difficileassociated disease cdad during an epidemic in quebec, canada. Does the canadian economy suffer from dutch disease.
Terms of trade changes, the dutch disease, and canadian provincial disparity pdf 509kb 20. The contract to produce the dutch disease paper ran from 2008 to 2009, and allowed the three authors to publish the work rather than have it remain internal to industry canada, which coulombe said. Holland sindromu iqtisadiyyatda xususi bir sektorda bas ver. Serge coulombe professor department of economics university of ottawa serge. A host of canadian politicians have blamed the woes of canadas manufacturers on dutch disease, but it turns out the sectors ills may be largely homegrown. This paper looks at whether immigration can mitigate the dutch disease effects associated with booms in natural resource sectors. Monitoring for tenofovir and entecavir toxicity 74 9.
Evidence from canadian provinces, the economic journal, 2015, vol125, issue 589, pp. Terms of trade changes, the dutch disease, and canadian provincial disparitymore. For more details or to schedule an interview, please contact the irpp. In the model, there is a nontradable sector which includes services and two tradable sectors.
The local economic e ffects of natural resource booms in modern america environmental regulation of oil and gas extraction. The author examines aspects of canadas trade performance in light of the major trends seen in world trade over the past several decades. Human capital quality and the immigrant wage gap, iza journal of migration 3. Feb 24, 2012 ontario is probably the province that has suffered the most from this, says university of ottawa economist serge coulombe, coauthor of a massive study on the impact of dutch disease on. Pdf dutch disease and the mitigation effect of migration. Dutch disease, natural resources, exchange rates, currency. Examining the dutch disease in twospeed economies pdf. This article evaluates whether immigration can mitigate the dutch disease effects associated with booms in natural resource sectors. Going dutch the impact of falling oil prices on the. Ottawa must play a stronger role to ensure that more. We argue that the failure to disentangle the evolution of the canadian currency and energy and commodity prices from the u.
Dutch disease, one version of which is that a natural resource boom draws factors of production from. The classic economic model describing dutch disease was developed by the economists w. Consequently, economists michel beine, charles bos, and serge coulombe investigated the impact of the increase of oil prices, the consequent spectacular development of the athabaska bitumen sands, and their impact on the canadian economy with a series of sophisticated statistical analyses in order to carefully separate dutch disease from other. We show that 63 percent of the manufacturing employment loss due to exchange rate development between 2002 and 2007 are related to a dutch disease phenomenon. Fluoroquinolones and risk for methicillinresistant. We argue that the failure to disentangle the evolution of the canadian currency from the u. The dutch disease and the canadian economy economics. The remaining 46 percent can be ascribed to the weakness of the us currency. Dutch disease and the mitigation effect of migration. Evidence from canadian provinces, crea discussion paper series 1206, center for research in economic analysis, university of luxembourg. Challenges for policymakers robin boadway, queens university serge coulombe, university of ottawa jeanfrancois tremblay, university of ottawa prepared for thinking outside the box, a conference in celebration of thomas j. Michel beine university of luxembourg serge coulombe university of ottawa and wessel vermeulen university of luxembourg dutch disease and mitigation effect of migration.
The role of the netherlands in the european framework for an international response on darfur during its presidency in 20042005. Evidence from canadian provinces, oxcarre working papers 151, oxford centre for the analysis of resource rich economies, university of oxford. Dutch elm disease ded is caused by a member of the sac fungi ascomycota affecting elm trees, and is spread by elm bark beetles. To determine the role of antimicrobial drugs in facilitating healthcareassociated methicillinresistant staphylococcus aureus mrsa colonization and infection and to compare this role with their effects on methicillinsusceptible s. Bos and serge coulombe abstract we argue that the failure to disentangle the evolution of the canadian currency from the u. Aug, 2010 in the end coulombe calculated that 53 per cent of the manufacturing employment loss a total of 322,000 jobs was directly related to a petro dollar and dutch disease phenomenon. Monitoring for disease progression and treatment response in persons with chb prior to, during and posttreatment 69 9. Feb 02, 2009 second, we estimate the separate impact of the two currency components on the shares of manufacturing employment in canada. Clean energy manufacturers spared from rising petrodollar. To receive our monthly bulletin thinking ahead by email, please subscribe to the irpps edistribution. Working papers institute of intergovernmental relations. Serge coulombe, an economy professor at the university of ottawa, and two european colleagues recently asked just how much of the manufacturing losses could be attributed to the. Evidence from canadian provinces, economic journal, royal economic society, vol. May 22, 2012 the contract to produce the dutch disease paper ran from 2008 to 2009, and allowed the three authors to publish the work rather than have it remain internal to industry canada, which coulombe said would have raised questions about its neutrality.
Pdf does the canadian economy suffer from dutch disease. By michel beine, charles bos and serge coulombe abstract we argue that the failure to disentangle the evolution of the canadian currency and energy and commodity prices from the us currency leads to potential wrong conclusions regarding the case of a dutch disease in canada. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. For example, coulombe 20, following krugman 1987, uses the somewhat softer term dutch affair to describe the potential for a positive oil. Issue 30 october 20 the canadian dollar and the dutch and. Serge coulombe, university of ottawa universite dottawa, economics. That is the central finding of research by michel beine, serge coulombe and wessel vermeulen, published in the december 2015 issue of. They implement a bayesian approach to assess how much the canadian dollar is associated with commodity prices, and then use that to show commodity price changes. May, 2012 for whatever this rightwing tool says, if she thinks the dutch disease has been long discredited she really should read this excellent report in this bc magazine. A new name for whats ailing canadian manufacturers wsj. Terms of trade changes, the dutch disease, and canadian provincial disparity more. Nov 01, 2012 dutch disease refers to the case where a resource boom in an economy leads to a real exchange appreciation and to the crowding out of the tradable manufacturing sector.
The booming sector is usually the extraction of natural resources such as oil, natural gas, gold, copper. Dutch disease is just one possible downside of a resource boom. Paper on dutch disease in the economic journal temporary foreign wokers and internal mobility journal of population economics last modified derniere modification 2019mars18. It is the first indepth study of the role of immigration as a mechanism for controlling dutch disease, where increased production of natural resources leads to a fall in the competitiveness of the manufacturing sector.
710 69 898 1385 99 103 324 1329 1380 1351 503 55 426 1152 189 726 421 1032 197 705 1461 1200 475 103 1594